QM Forum

Islamic Secondary Sources => Discussions => Topic started by: Wakas on September 08, 2025, 08:09:12 AM

Title: A simple yet devastating argument against hadith?
Post by: Wakas on September 08, 2025, 08:09:12 AM
I've been using this one for a while but not sure if I posted it:

Hadith advocates who think whatever prophet said or enacted was revelation and thus worthy of it being recorded later as hadith.


The reply:

No and this is proven from Quran itself.

33:53 tells us explicitly not to wait around for PROPHET'S hadith.
If they were critical for us it would be impossible for God to say this, because it would be akin to turning them away those seeking knowledge.
Exactly what God rebukes prophet for in chapter 80 for shunning a blind man who was possibly seeking the truth.

God contradicts Himself according to them.

Thus if their position is true it creates an internal contradiction and disproves their God and Quran.


Then the final blow is 66:3-5
It reprimands prophets wives for spreading PROPHET'S hadith here.

Thus the sahabah cannot wait around for prophets hadith nor spread them.



Case closed.


Game over?