QM Forum

The Quran => Q&As with Joseph Islam - Information Only => Topic started by: Beyond Tradition on May 30, 2018, 03:30:39 PM

Title: Permanent Protection of Birth Control
Post by: Beyond Tradition on May 30, 2018, 03:30:39 PM
Dear Brother Joseph Islam,
As-Salamualikum ,

Hope you are in peach and happiness by the grace of the God.
I am in big problem . I can not take decision if I should have my wife to restrict permanently for birth a child .
She already gave birth 3 child within 12 years our marital life . All the time she had to take surgery at the time of delivery .
Her health will never allow for conceiving intentionally or unintentionally in the future . She has high pressure and physically not remain good all the time . Though we were practicing temporary birth control method but it may cause for incident again . When situation like this
should I have my wife to take permanent protection of not conceiving any more . Pls give me your humble thought in this matter in Quran's perspective.


B/Rgds
Beyond Tradition.   
Title: Re: Permanent Protection of Birth Control
Post by: Beyond Tradition on May 31, 2018, 05:49:27 PM

Dear Brother Joseph Islam,
As-Salamualikum ,

Brother , I totally understand your busy schedules. But I need yur humble opinion on this topics .  So please if you would kindly reply and help me out. Thank you
Title: Re: Permanent Protection of Birth Control
Post by: QM Moderators Team on May 31, 2018, 08:46:45 PM
Beyond Tradition,

You have asked this question yesterday and are chasing up on a response today? Can you please understand that it is against the forum policy to badger for responses (2d)?

Please kindly refrain from doing this in the future!

Thanks.
Title: Re: Permanent Protection of Birth Control
Post by: Joseph Islam on May 31, 2018, 11:26:54 PM
Quote from: Beyond Tradition on May 30, 2018, 03:30:39 PM
Dear Brother Joseph Islam,
As-Salamualikum ,

Hope you are in peach and happiness by the grace of the God.
I am in big problem . I can not take decision if I should have my wife to restrict permanently for birth a child .
She already gave birth 3 child within 12 years our marital life . All the time she had to take surgery at the time of delivery .
Her health will never allow for conceiving intentionally or unintentionally in the future . She has high pressure and physically not remain good all the time . Though we were practicing temporary birth control method but it may cause for incident again . When situation like this
should I have my wife to take permanent protection of not conceiving any more . Pls give me your humble thought in this matter in Quran's perspective.


B/Rgds
Beyond Tradition.   


Wa alaikum assalam

In my humble view, if it can be determined by specialist / expert medical practitioners in that branch of medicine that a woman is at serious risk of illness (beyond doubt) or even death post another pregnancy, then in those specific circumstances, there is an argument that a permanent procedure could be possible. This is as long as the woman provides her consent (without any coercion whatsoever) to have that permanent / irreversible procedure in the first place and there is a serious medical risk to her health.

Opinions of general practitioners or self-assessments of health looking at superficial markers in my humble opinion, do not qualify as expert medical input.

Regards,
Joseph
Title: Re: Permanent Protection of Birth Control
Post by: Beyond Tradition on June 04, 2018, 06:33:47 PM
Brother , Joseph,
Thank you so much as you responded my question within your much busy time .
May Allah keep you in peach and happiness and give opportunity to serve the people who are in religion dark .

B/Rgds
Beyond Tradition.