QM Forum

The Quran => Q&As with Joseph Islam - Information Only => Topic started by: Reader Comments on June 22, 2012, 12:29:06 AM

Title: Learning the Quran through Dictionaries Alone
Post by: Reader Comments on June 22, 2012, 12:29:06 AM

From Mubashir Inayat
Sent: 05 June 2012

Salam Brother
 
Just want to share a comment on Facebook with a Br. Aurangzaib, who was once associated with Dr. Qamaruzzaman's aastan.com (learning Qur'a through dictionary alone).
 
We were analysing the meaning of Muslim and Momin.
 
Mubashir

Title: Re: Learning the Quran through Dictionaries Alone
Post by: Joseph Islam on June 22, 2012, 12:32:17 AM

Initial response: 05 June 2012


Salamun Alaikum

I have a question for you. It is basically for those (not your kind self) that attempt to understand the Quran mainly through dictionaries.

If we cannot rely on hadith which is a secondary source of the second century AH+, how can we rely on the dictionaries which have also been influenced by the same people in the second century AH+ and is also a secondary source?

What would you say if I said, I am going to learn Urdu from dictionaries only to undersand Ghalib? As a native Urdu speaker what would you say to me?

Now think, what would a native Arab say?