Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Topics - Beyond Tradition

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4
16
Dear Brother Joseph
Salamun Alaikum , my question is ,  was Prophet Musa (PBUH) Muslim or Jews ?
Similarly was Prophet Jesus ( PBUH) Christian ? Why God mentioned the followers of Prophet Musa and Prophet Jesus  respectively Jews and Christian ? What is the meaning of Jews and Christian in Quran’s perspective ? We call Muslim who surrender himself completely  to the will of God . In a same point of view why Jews and Christian were not Muslim ? Do you think Muslim stands as only religion name not describes as meaning ?



17
Dear Brother Joseph ,
Salamun Alaikum . Many Muslims tells that it is duty for a Muslim to form a Islamic country where he lives in or joined with other who wants to form it in any other country . My question how a Muslim can confirm correct laws from Quran and get the best meaning from it. Not only that in Morden world when a Muslim lives in a Non Islamic country ( majority non Muslim ) then how he violate rules of that country where he lives in ? Please advise your humble opinion. To create a Islamic republic of country is Quran mentioned clearly ? What level of compromising for a Muslim in a non Islamic country?

18
Dear Brother Joseph
Salamun Alaikum . Sometimes I have been asked from my many fellows that is death is predeceased by God with time and day ?
God knows that time and day ? I believe without any question that God knows everything what has happened and what will happen.
My question is,   is Quran mentioned anywhere that death of human is pre-decided and men never can change his death time/period by his good deeds ? If so why we pray to God for the long life of our lives or we pray for others same ? If you have any thought pls input .

Many things will be cleared in the Day of Judgement and I believe that day all men ( believers or disbelievers)  will acknowledge that no unjust is applied to them .

19

Dear Brother Joseph
As sala mualikum , I have corrected some words for this topics .
I need to know that is  semen (sperm) of human really called as profane  or unholy water ? ?
Many Muslims scholar says human is created from a drop of profane water (semen ).
Is there any verse can interpreted semen as profane or unholy water . It means not pure , bad, etc...
That is why after intercourse Gusal ( take bath) is compulsory before starting any work or saying Salah/prayer .
My question is how man is created from a worst or inferior things when all mighty God created mankind and proffered on many of His creatures? I know there are some verses and Muslim scholars are interpreting wrong . Please make me clear in Quran’s perspective about "a drop of profane water " . Thank you .

20
Dear Brother Joseph ,
As sa la mu alaikum. I was looking for best opinion in Qurans’s perspective that how I can pay zakat against gold ornament of my wife . She is really  concern about this and telling me to give her a answer what she do. I got many comments , thought  from this forum and read your article on Zakah
To hear all voices it seemed to me  paying Taxes on income will full fill the purpose of zakah.
So please is really need to pay zakat against idle gold ( which not make money) ? If I need to pay then how many ? I know Quran not  specified any amount or percentage so how I can determine the amount of zakat I need to pay against idle gold? And also whom I should pay ?

Brother Joseph , I will be grateful to you if you give your humble opinion.
Leave the matter on me whether I accept or not.

Thank you .

21
Dear Brother Joseph ,
Ramadan Kareem. As - Sa - La- Mualikum .
Per my understanding Quran makes the specific time for 5 times salah and fasting based on Sun rising and drowning .
My question is , how a Muslim understand the time of Salah where ( some countries like Norway, Osolo , Kopen hegen etc.. ) day is much longer than night . On the other hand in some countries there is no day for several months . or in some where 6 months night and six months day . I am not 100% sure about this variance of the day and night but I have had heard . So question is raised that how Muslim eat Seheri and Iftar in ramadan in those country ? similarly will perform Salah ?  My thought is Quran must have anything on this time issue when it specified time for five times Salah  and because God knows about the climate of all countries .  I have very limited knowledge of this time zone . Please input your thought on this or share me the artical where you already discussed about this topics.

Thank you .

22
Dear Brother Joseph
As-sa Lamualikum . Ramadan Kareem . May Allah keep you in good health .
I have been tired to get specific answer ( YEs or NO ) regarding performing  Salah ( Farz/Compulsory) . You told there is no problem to perform Salah with congregation as traditional form . My question is , can I perform salah ( Farz/Compulsory) alone in my house ? Does Quran permit muslim to perform Salah alone in his house ? If I perform farz Salah ( Fazar , Johar, Asar ,Magrib , Esha ) alone in my house then can I say any number of rakat ? Traditional prayer has a certain rakat but most of the time I can not count or remember the number of rakat in my prayer . I will be glad if you give me time to make this understand . This is Ramadan Month . I will be much grateful if you share how you perform Salah in Ramadan Month ? You just can give your position on your personal practice . I normally do not debate on any topics and just hear and if I get best meaning and thought I accept to follow .

Thank you

23
Dear Brother Joseph ,
As Sa la Mualikum , Brother I did not read Quran fully with translation . So I have much lack of knowledge regarding many of verses if exsit or not . Most of the Muslims utter the words  in case of any crisis or as prayer " La Ilaha Illalahu Mohammadur Rasulullah "  My question is whenever they steps to worship to God they added the name of the Prophet Mohammed (SM) PBUH . They think without added Prophet Mohammad ( PBUH) worship to God will not be perfect . That is why , in 5 times prayer it is fixed (Doa) a part . My question is , is there the  complete verse " La Ilaha Illalahu Mohammadur Rasulullah " in Quran ? if yes then should Muslim utter this verse will trend to the partnership of God with Prophet Mohammed ? or If God added Phophet Mohammed (SM) then did God grade the position between messengers ? But I know the explicit verses in Quran states not to make any difference between messengers .  To me Many Muslims doing same about Prophet Mohammed (SM) like Jesus Christ . Please tell me in detail about the words " La Ilaha Illalahu Mohammadur Rasulullah " . It is written , headed at the top of mosque gate , uttered regularly ......

Thank you .

24
Dear brother Joseph
As Salamualikum. I need to know is Bible scripture of God? Do Christian and Jews believe in one God ?
and Day of Judgement ? In which sense directly you reject them as non-believers ? What is the basic needs to be a Muslim according to Quran. 

25
Dear Brother Joseph
Salamun Alaikum . My another important question is to you that is 6 weeks of pregnancy ( According to blood test report) create lives in the womb of a female ? If any women not physically fit  or no medical and regular care available in her family  then will she be permuted to
remove this 6 weeks pregnancy ? If it already created lives then will it not be seen for killing the lives ? I have a relative facing this situation . She is not physically FIT and often she remain sick and moreover there are nobody to look after her in her family on the other hand she has already two children ( one is 2 yards old ) so it definitely will be at risk for her to birth another baby . So please input your thought in Quran's perspective . In verse of the Quran " do not kill your baby due to only poverty " I do not understand from the verse that which stage of pregnancy we can call lives when God instructed not to kill afraid of poverty ? 

I share an absolute true event that my own sister conceived a baby for about 4 months ( per medical term matured enough ) . But suddenly she was attacked with both malaria and typhoid ( bad fiver ) and her health condition was so bad that doctor said to save her live 4 months baby must be removed by crashing in her womb . And at this stage every will give judgement to remove 4 months baby.
And finally we removed baby . I think God is merciful .







26
General Discussions / Death pain in Qurans perspective
« on: April 14, 2019, 05:06:33 AM »
Dear Brother Joseph
As- salamualikum . I always hankering after your input of my any topics. I hope if you get time you
Will input your thought on my said topics.

Many Scolars , many Muslims try to measure the death pain or pain at the point of death. My philosophy or judgement based on Quran death is a normal phenomenon for human life. So far I know I did not find that Quran says anything about the pain at the point of death. It will come on a sudden and take away the soul of human being and will enter in Barjakh where time concept is lost. I never find or never heard that God describes about the pain at the death point . He alarms only to fear the Day of resurction and hell fire where severe pain of fire is waiting . But now many muslim scholar and in Islami secondary sources states that prophet Mohammad discribed the pain at his death point and sought to all mighty some waive of pain to his followers. Per Islami secondary sources prophet Mohammad has been given a extreme less of pain what he was not bearing and was thinking for his
followers how they will bear this death pain. Where prophet himself received death with a very cordial
process by angel of death but it was so severe than his followers will receive 100 times severe than Prophet Mohammad (Pbuh). My question in earthly capacity men can die within a second like in explosive , in gun point etc... so how this life suffer severe pain at the point of death. Moreover , why God will give  someone severe pain based on his bad deeds in the earth. If so then without trial how God can apply severe death pain to a men ? Pls input your thought .

27
Dear Brother Joseph ,
I like you to input your thought on this thread. Many scholars try to show example of methemetical linguistic miracle of many Surah like Al Bakara ( Surah # 2) has 286 verses. And middle of this Surah the verse number # 143 which state middle nation .....
beside this they try to prove the athenticity of the Quran by showing some miracle methemetical consistency from many Surah . My question is , this type of methemetical consistency really significant to invite non believers to accept Quoran’s message as God’s scripture ? Some scholar try to prove the athenticity of the Quran when science is discovering the truth which was stated in Quran 1400  years ago . My question is also , was God waiting for the advanced world when men will discover the truth ? If so then what was the use of those Surah and verses for the people 1400 years ago ? I hope you are getting my points .  Pls input your thought .

Thanks . God bless you.

28

Dear all .
Salamun Alaikum . I basically like the way of analyzing of brother Joseph A. Islam regarding Quran and it's all verses . I also like that he nevr base the Hadth ( Islami secondary sources ) to get best meaning of any verse from the Quran. There are 1.4 million Hadith which created many contradiction between verses . As a result many Christian Scholars refer those hadith to degradation of Quran's message. I am praying to all mighty Allah for his live long and give opportunity to spread the knowledge to among the people to take the truth .  I always try to hear many debates between Christian scholars like David Wodd , Mike Licona, Samual Green , and Muslim Scholars like Ahmed Deedat , Shabit Ali , Mohhamed Hijab , Jakir Nyak etc...... My questions is why brother Jospeh Islam not participate in this type of debate in the world or not published in you-tube or social media ?  Nodybody in my area knows about such highly scholars (I have ever seen  ) .  Please answer anybody on this topic the reason of wisdom for him to not disclose or spread his knowledge .


 


29
General Discussions / Do women say Salah during menstruation ?
« on: March 25, 2019, 06:41:57 PM »
Dear Brother Joseph
Salamun Alaikum . I have gone through your thread that women can fast during menstruation if not feel sick .
But I did not find if women can say Salah at this time . Please make me clear .

30
Dear Brother Joseph,
Salamun Alaikum . I gone through your significant thread about Zakat and understand there is no fixation on Zakat for Muslim .
My question is I am paying income tax to the government . Is Zakat and Salah Farj for any individuals or any community ?
Since Quran mentioned for Zakah and Salah simultaneously so is it the compulsory for a government to established Zakat and Salah ?
If the Chief of the State Non Muslim ( Disbeliever)  then how a Muslim  ( Believer ) can establish Salah and Zakat ?  If Zakat means Tax on income then will it be okay for a Muslim when Government is not a Muslim  ? Sadaka is different and any Muslim can spend any amount to the specific ground what Quran specified already . But about Zakah there is no mention ( may be )  where  it should be spent .
Is Zakat Farj against idle preserved ornament ( gold) belong to a spouse ? Many Muslim teacher here give a "Fatoa" that Zakah must be paid on idle gold which preserved at home belonging a women . I can not justify this concept in the light of  Quran .   

Please make me clear to follow the instructions from God .

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4