4:15-4:16

Started by Amira, November 24, 2016, 06:34:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Amira

Hi everyone :)

I was reading 4:15-16 earlier, and although I've noticed their discrepancy before, I didn't pay much attention to it. However, does anyone know why the punishment for lewdness for a woman is indefinite confinement with no guarantee of release following repentance? 4:16 dictates forgiveness if the 2 men involved repent. Is it because 4:15 may be referring to prostitution, while 4:16 is more similar to one-off adultery?
"Narrated Buraydah ibn al-Hasib: I heard the Apostle of Allah say: In eloquence there is magic, in knowledge ignorance, and in poetry wisdom"

"Historically, what is or isn't mainstream (in Islam) has always been a function of power, not of truth." (Iyad El-Baghdadi, Arab Spring activist)

Amira

In addition, 4:15 states that four reliable witnesses must be obtained before carrying out punishment. 4:16 has no such requirement, but seems to show more laxity with regard to the prescribed penalty.
"Narrated Buraydah ibn al-Hasib: I heard the Apostle of Allah say: In eloquence there is magic, in knowledge ignorance, and in poetry wisdom"

"Historically, what is or isn't mainstream (in Islam) has always been a function of power, not of truth." (Iyad El-Baghdadi, Arab Spring activist)

wanderer

TOTALLY DIFFERENT PUNISHMENTS FOR TOTALLY DIFFERENT CRIMES
4:15- Major lewdness (fahisha) committed by 3+ women
4:16- Male Homosexuality (2 men)
Regards
wanderer
Rather, We dash the truth upon falsehood, and it destroys it, and thereupon it departs. And for you is destruction from that which you describe. (21:18)

wanderer

And yes, you are right, 4:15 seems to primarily indicate prostitution, though this is not the only form of major fahisha.
See the end notes for Brother Joseph's article on Homosexuality.
The phrase 'until God ordains for them another way', in 4:15, in my opinion, constitutes an acceptance of possible repentance on part of the women. (Also see end of Joseph's article on abrogation)
Also, just because the punishment in 4:16 is undefined, this does not signify laxity. Undefined means just that--undefined.
Regards
wanderer
Rather, We dash the truth upon falsehood, and it destroys it, and thereupon it departs. And for you is destruction from that which you describe. (21:18)

Amira

Thank you for your answers. Why is it 3+ women in 4:15? Some Arabic grammatical rule? The verse says "any of your women".
"Narrated Buraydah ibn al-Hasib: I heard the Apostle of Allah say: In eloquence there is magic, in knowledge ignorance, and in poetry wisdom"

"Historically, what is or isn't mainstream (in Islam) has always been a function of power, not of truth." (Iyad El-Baghdadi, Arab Spring activist)

wanderer

Joseph's endnotes on his Homosexuality article talks it about it. He also has a Q&A that goes into more depth, but I can't find it right now.
You can read it here: http://quransmessage.com/articles/homosexuality%20FM3.htm
Regards
wanderer
Rather, We dash the truth upon falsehood, and it destroys it, and thereupon it departs. And for you is destruction from that which you describe. (21:18)

Hamzeh

Asalamu Alykum

Good answer brother Wanderer

The other article that Wanderer might be referring to is below. Insha'Allah it will explain your inquiries
I would also see the related article about rape, as one notes how punishment may increase for acts from prostitution to rape


http://quransmessage.com/forum/index.php?topic=319.0

wanderer

Rather, We dash the truth upon falsehood, and it destroys it, and thereupon it departs. And for you is destruction from that which you describe. (21:18)

Amira

This makes more sense now. Thank you all for your input :)
"Narrated Buraydah ibn al-Hasib: I heard the Apostle of Allah say: In eloquence there is magic, in knowledge ignorance, and in poetry wisdom"

"Historically, what is or isn't mainstream (in Islam) has always been a function of power, not of truth." (Iyad El-Baghdadi, Arab Spring activist)

Amira

Hi, I'm still confused as to why 4:16 does not stipulate a witness requirement. Wouldn't it be more fair to have a 4 witness requirement in all such cases?
"Narrated Buraydah ibn al-Hasib: I heard the Apostle of Allah say: In eloquence there is magic, in knowledge ignorance, and in poetry wisdom"

"Historically, what is or isn't mainstream (in Islam) has always been a function of power, not of truth." (Iyad El-Baghdadi, Arab Spring activist)

wanderer

4:16 says if two men are guilty, punish them both. They have already been proven guilty, which means that witnesses are implied.
Regards
wanderer
Rather, We dash the truth upon falsehood, and it destroys it, and thereupon it departs. And for you is destruction from that which you describe. (21:18)