Show Posts
1
Islamic Duties / Kaaba being taken from the polytheists
« on: October 09, 2017, 12:09:16 AM »
Salam everyone 
I was reading this article http://quransmessage.com/articles/makkah%20bakkah%20FM3.htm and there is one thing I can't understand.
According to the article, the Kaaba was never built by Abraham (PBUH) but it was originally a polytheistic temple.
To me this explanation makes sense, but does this mean that at one point Muhammad (PBUH) stole the polytheists' place of worship and made it his own?
This is the only thing that I can't accept. Reading the Qur'an I realise that we should always respect other faiths, even if we don't believe in them. When God says in 3:20, 5:92, 13:40, 16:82, 42:48 "if they turn away your only duty is to deliver the message" it's making clear that there has to be no compulsion in Islam. So why would Muhammad (PBUH) ever decide to take their place of worship? Couldn't he build another one? How was this respectful of their religion (the polytheistic religion)?
I hope you will help me!
I was reading this article http://quransmessage.com/articles/makkah%20bakkah%20FM3.htm and there is one thing I can't understand.
According to the article, the Kaaba was never built by Abraham (PBUH) but it was originally a polytheistic temple.
To me this explanation makes sense, but does this mean that at one point Muhammad (PBUH) stole the polytheists' place of worship and made it his own?
This is the only thing that I can't accept. Reading the Qur'an I realise that we should always respect other faiths, even if we don't believe in them. When God says in 3:20, 5:92, 13:40, 16:82, 42:48 "if they turn away your only duty is to deliver the message" it's making clear that there has to be no compulsion in Islam. So why would Muhammad (PBUH) ever decide to take their place of worship? Couldn't he build another one? How was this respectful of their religion (the polytheistic religion)?
I hope you will help me!