Messages

76

General Discussions / Spend Money (For Charity, Festival or Feed the Poor) For Sake of Dead Person

« on: March 19, 2019, 09:30:23 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph ,
Salamun Alaikum . It is very commonly seen that we many Muslim spend money for sake of  the dead persons like for one's father or relatives  . This money is spent for charity , or  reform mosque , or  feeding poor , or festival among the relatives and neighbors so that departed soul stay in peace in the grave ( Quran not mentioned for the punishment in the grave )  or accountability of the dead person will be easy to God in the day of Judgement .  Per my knowledge Quran's only allow to pray for the dead ( janaja salah ) .  My question is there any explicit verse or verses to approve this kind of practice when all the spent for sake of dead persons can change the fate of the dead person in the Day of judgement ? If time permit you pls put your thought .

Thank you .

77

General Discussions / Re: Hajj is Compulsory for the Believers?

« on: March 18, 2019, 03:35:31 PM »

Dear Brother ,
My intention was not that I do not want to perform pilgrimage . I want to know what Quran syas to perform Haj .
You told there is no compulsory in religion ...... I respectfully disagree with you when Salah ( 5 times / 4 times whatever ...) is compulsory for the believers mentioned in the Quran .

I expect brother Joseph will manage his time to give me his thought in this topics .

78

General Discussions / Re: Recitation of Quran in Arabic Without Knowing Meaning is Blessing for Us

« on: March 18, 2019, 03:26:33 PM »

Dear Brother ,
Peace be upon you . You answered exactly what in my mind . This is just absolute logic per Quran's perspective .
But still now it is prevailing that many hadith states that only recitation of the Quran without any understanding ( specific sura , verses etc... ) can benefit us for the recover of any crisis we are facing . It is mentioned that recitation of some verses or sura will give you give us Jannah , will not put us into trouble , some of them will make you rich , some of them will benefit us for many obstacles etc......
It is also mentioned if recitation of some specific sura , verses tow times , three times will benefit us . Many Muslims is practicing like this way .......  Some times it is mentioned of some story ,  event  as the proof of the recitation of the partly Quran or it's verses . For Example ... If any one recites a certain sura three times daily he never face poverty ..   

I will be glad if any one of this forum can give me strong evidence that no benefit will come to us either in earthly life  or in after world only recitation of the Quran without understanding .

Best/Rgds.

79

General Discussions / Quran is the scripture from God - Without acknowledging Kaliphs

« on: March 14, 2019, 08:44:25 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph ,
Salamun Alai Kum .  I myself  believe and ther is no doubt that Quran is the scripture from God . But for non believers how I can proof when I can not keep traditional belief on Hadith and four Khalips . We know complete Quran as a book furnished by Hazrat Usman .
I hope you can refresh my mind to understand this topic.

Many Muslims says without Hadith we can not understand Quran clearly and they take help of 2nd book where God question to believers/nonbelievers  for accepting other book than Quran . 

Since Mohammed ( PUBH) not present now in 21th century so how we can understand Quran without Hadith ?

I am accepting that there are many contradictory hadith with Quran . But if there had not been any contradiction between hadith and Quran then would there have been logic to accept Hadith to understand Quran when God clearly mentioned " what other book you prefer than Quran" or Quran is the book where everything is in detailed and easy " ?

Please make me clear .

80

General Discussions / Punishment in the grave

« on: March 14, 2019, 08:24:51 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph
Salamun Alaikum ,
Brother  I have gone through your article " Punishment in Grave " and understand that there is no mention of such type of punishment before the day of resurrection . Sometimes Many Muslims Quote the verse ( 102:1 )  from Sura AT TAKA SUR " AL HAKU MUTTAKA SURU HATTA JURUTU mulma quber " Here I got "Quber" means after the die . not specifically meaning that the place where any one is buried .
If translate in English it mean grave . So the meaning of the verse stand " you will know the truth soon  after the die (grave ?) . Then you see hell "   My question how you will explain this verse in the proof of no punishment in the grave ?

My understanding is since , for all on the Day of Judgement everybody will feel that they just have slept for an hour or a part of the day so God can say in His verse that  it should be a very short time that one will see the hell . 

Please make me clear of the above verse .




 

81

General Discussions / Hajj is Compulsory for the Believers?

« on: March 14, 2019, 05:45:57 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph ,
Salamun Alai Kum . I need to know very specifically if one not perform Hajj evan he has the capacity of performing Hajj at least once in his earthly  life ? Or in which conditions  it is compulsory for one to be performed Haj ? We are seeing many Mulims performing Haj not only once but also several times in every year and spend huge money  to perform Haj when in his locality many poor , neighbor are in huge crisis and he never work on mankind in his locality . I do not know on what basis or condition God established Haj to a man or women ?

Now Many Muslims do perform Haz 2 times 3 times or more and in Saudi Arabia is organizing this holy Haj convention by a commercial thinking . Some can stay at big hotel and  some can  stay in very contested area  as they have no capacity to spend days with luxurious. I am afraid of really Haj now is prevailing is the exactly what God has prescribed to believers ?

Also It will be great help for me if any one on this forum can give me answer .


 

82

General Discussions / Recitation of Quran in Arabic Without Knowing Meaning is Blessing for Us

« on: March 14, 2019, 05:25:34 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph ,
Salamun Alai kum . Brother , Many Muslims suggests to recite Quran for the believers of who does not know Arabic language . Recitation Quran no matter one understand the meaning of what God is prescribing but it is blessings from God to the reciters as it is word from God . I will be glad if you can put your thought in Quran's perspective .

 

83

General Discussions / Menstruation

« on: March 14, 2019, 05:09:21 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph ,
As sala - muali- kum , Firstly I pray for your long life and sound health to All Mighty God .
Brother , my question is ......  do women can say  prayer ( Salah) in a condition of menstruation ? I gone through your article " Menstruation" where I did know that there is no explicit prohibition for women  not to fast . But I need to know very specific if women can say salah in a condition of mensuration or she must wait until it is fully cleansed ?

84

Islamic Duties / Re: SACRIFICING ANIMALS FOR THE GIVING BIRTH A CHILD

« on: July 11, 2018, 06:01:29 PM »

Dear All in this forum
As Sala Mualikum . Can anybody help me to get answer my below topics ?

Thank you.

85

Islamic Duties / SACRIFICING ANIMALS FOR THE GIVING BIRTH A CHILD

« on: June 27, 2018, 07:14:05 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph
As Sala Mualikum . We are observing  in Muslim community that people prescribe for sacrificing animals for giving birth a new child .
They prescribe for a birthing a male child  two goats  to be slaughtered and to be distributed to the needy or festival among the neighbors and relatives . For giving birth a female child  1 goat is sectioned . My question is Quran prescribe this type of practice ? If yes then what will be the poor family who has no capacity to buy the goats .  It is very hard for me to believe that Quran prescribe this type of practice which may create the force income to do this practice for the poor . Or any general practice Quran never prescribe different for the rich and poor like prayer . Pls take me out off the dark .

Thank you.

86

Q&As with Joseph Islam - Information Only / Re: Permanent Protection of Birth Control

« on: June 04, 2018, 06:33:47 PM »

Brother , Joseph,
Thank you so much as you responded my question within your much busy time .
May Allah keep you in peach and happiness and give opportunity to serve the people who are in religion dark .

B/Rgds
Beyond Tradition.

87

Islamic Duties / PERMENANT BIRTH CONTROL

« on: June 02, 2018, 07:20:52 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph Islam,
As-Salamualikum ,

Hope you are in peach and happiness by the grace of the God.
I am in big problem . I can not take decision if I should have my wife to restrict permanently for birth a child .
She already gave birth 3 child within 12 years our marital life . All the time she had to take surgery at the time of delivery .
Her health will never allow for conceiving intentionally or unintentionally in the future . She has high pressure and physically not remain good all the time . Though we were practicing temporary birth control method but it may cause for incident again . When situation like this
should I have my wife to take permanent protection of not conceiving any more . Pls give me your humble thought in this matter in Quran's perspective.


B/Rgds
Beyond Tradition.   

88

Islamic Duties / ZAKAT

« on: May 31, 2018, 05:57:52 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph Islam,
As-Salamualikum ,

Per my study and review your many articles and answer on Jakat it seems to me Zakat should be collected by the government of certain community . It is not something that can be distribute to any needy person by any individual. It is also understand that there is no specific percentage of the asset or income is designated to give Zakat for a person . But in the Quran in many places says for Salat and Zakat together . When my government is not stand on Quranic decision to direct the society so what I should follow the verse about Zakat . Pls advise your opinion how I can fix the amount for Zakat and to distribute .

B/Rgds
Beyond Tradition .

89

Q&As with Joseph Islam - Information Only / Re: Permanent Protection of Birth Control

« on: May 31, 2018, 05:49:27 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph Islam,
As-Salamualikum ,

Brother , I totally understand your busy schedules. But I need yur humble opinion on this topics .  So please if you would kindly reply and help me out. Thank you

90

Q&As with Joseph Islam - Information Only / Permanent Protection of Birth Control

« on: May 30, 2018, 03:30:39 PM »

Dear Brother Joseph Islam,
As-Salamualikum ,

Hope you are in peach and happiness by the grace of the God.
I am in big problem . I can not take decision if I should have my wife to restrict permanently for birth a child .
She already gave birth 3 child within 12 years our marital life . All the time she had to take surgery at the time of delivery .
Her health will never allow for conceiving intentionally or unintentionally in the future . She has high pressure and physically not remain good all the time . Though we were practicing temporary birth control method but it may cause for incident again . When situation like this
should I have my wife to take permanent protection of not conceiving any more . Pls give me your humble thought in this matter in Quran's perspective.


B/Rgds
Beyond Tradition.