Salaat Forum

[Sardar Miyan]

Assalam Bro JAI I felt sorry to see that inpite of your clear explanation Dr Shabbir has now come to Hamdanis rescue by upholding his views on Saum.I think it is like Dr Qamaruzzamas views on Saum.I do noit know why in so many placesc Allah use Idiomotic Arabic when  He has to convey a message. Fasting is a practice coming from ages 1400 years ago. These people are trying to creat new concept which needs to be resolved. How can these Non Arab understand Arabic better than arabs themselves? You are explaining well but they are bent upon deniying.

[Joseph Islam]

Dear brother,

Salamun Alaikum.

Thank you for your comments. One can only provide clear proofs and evidence. The rest is a matter for God to decide. In my humble view, I have felt that I have provided clear evidence and requested clear proof for my academic contentions. The outcome can be read on the thread by anyone with a viable internet connection around the world.

Hitherto, I have not read any convincing evidence to my contentions.

I am also aware that for some people, no matter what evidence you provide, they will not accept the truth.

002:006
"Behold as for those that are bent on denying the truth - It is all one to them whether you warn them or warn them not, they will not believe"

002:007
"God has sealed their heart, ears and their hearing and over their eyes is a veil and an awesome suffering awaits"

Now I cannot speak for Dr. Shabbir or anyone else as I have no knowledge even of my own fate. All I can do is provide the best evidence sincerely with the best knowledge that has reached me, God willing.

I leave judgment only with God.

Your brother in faith,
Joseph.