Brother Optimist/ Abdul Samad,
Salamun Alaikum.
Please kindly allow the readers to discern the works of an individual if you do decide to kindly share them on this forum and form their own opinions, rather than pinning titles such as 'living legend' and those of the like.
The forum moderators have already kindly, yet repeatedly, warned you about scholar reverence on this forum. Please take this once again as a sincere gentle reminder.
However, thank you so much for sharing the useful information that you have shared which I am sure many readers will also find interesting. I have already been alighted to the fact that you have shared this view by Ali Manikfan on a thread on another forum. Readers can peruse the contents of that conversation and glean your perspective in more detail below. Sadly I also felt that at times the conversation unnecessarily descended into chaos and Ad Hominem, although I may add, no fault of your own.
http://ourbeaconforum.com/cgi-bin/bbs60x/webbbs_config.pl/page/1/md/read/id/314123119179841I would somewhat incline to respectfully disagree with what I feel 'may' be an 'insinuation' on your part (given your thread above and the post on this thread) and your statement below, even though you are correct that a present 'solar' calendar is not ipso facto endorsed by the Quran.
So any calendar system without taking into account the phases of the moon is not Quranic, even if they are reliable.
I have shared my general perspective on this below. Albeit there is common ground in our views, I think we do reach somewhat differing conclusions which I kindly share with readers for their perusal.
http://quransmessage.com/forum/index.php?topic=171Regards,
Joseph.
RELATED ARTICLE:[1] MOON SIGHTINGhttp://quransmessage.com/articles/moonsighting%20FM3.htm