Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Ismail

Pages: 1 ... 12 13 [14] 15 16
196
Islamic Duties / Re: The real purpose of ablution
« on: October 17, 2013, 01:57:48 AM »
Salaam.

You said:

“I did some research and found that ablution mostly isn't about physical cleansing but more about freeing your mind of thoughts. Why? It's because when you wash your face with the water, your heart rate lowers which in turn makes you more relaxed. The phenomenon is called "mammalian diving reflex.”

Thank you for the scientific revelation. I am always waiting for such information, in order to pounce upon it and devour it. It is my passion.

Ordinarily, I have always profoundly felt the salutary effect of washing the face with water. What a world of difference washing makes to our mental state apart from the physical benefits! Nevertheless, water is such a blessed thing! “And We send down from the sky water charged with blessing…” (50:9-10-11).

The following is partly the result of my reflections on certain remarks in Thafseer Bayanullinnas (urdu) by Kwaja Ahmeduddeen of Amritsar, India, written during the 2nd quarter of the last century :

In Al Quran there are two remarks praising cleanliness in general: 2:222, & 9:108.

Of course they are general statements.

After all, with respect to every human being, the need to clean oneself from extreme filth arises every day. And the extreme importance of such cleanliness, everyone recognizes unequivocally. Therefore the Quran doesn’t mention it in so many words.

According to the above mentioned Thafseer, Wudu is especially for congregational prayers, and, even there, it is only optional.

It is speculated, not without reason, that over and above man’s natural habit of cleansing himself of extreme filth, he is being asked to present himself as much as possible fresh and glowing in public especially while performing congregational religious service.

Moreover, the numerous masail (issues and solutions) much adored in the corridors of religion, are man-made, and irrelevant to changing times. Habitual repression (in the name of ‘guarding’ Wudu) of the poisonous filth that collects in our intestines may cause leaching of harmful germs and other poison into the bloodstream, and thus pollute the whole body. 

Thayammum does impart a degree of freshness.

I have seen flocks of birds in the woods performing dust-bath in the evening before retiring for the night, during summer, when water is scarce.

Also, earth is a convenient, universally available - although not a thorough - aid for cleansing in an emergency, like in a parched countryside, until water is made available.

Thayammum also is, like Wudu, described as a consummation of the basic cleanse, and the basic cleanse is not described in so many words.

The traditionalists would have it that that is where the importance of hadees becomes manifest!

Instead, this is where the dire need to use our God-given intellect becomes manifest:

“…And He puts filth upon those who do not use their intellect.” (10:100)

This stand of the Qur’an is diametrically opposite to what religious leaders would have us believe: that we should not question religious injunctions, for they are beyond human intelligence!

Of course, man-made interpolations into virgin religion are straightaway detectable by the intellect.

Allah is categorical that even virgin religion should stand the test of intelligent inquiry.

Throughout the Qur’an, Allah appeals to our intelligence. 

So God bless your quest to find the rationale behind Wudu and Thyammum. 

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.


197
Islamic Duties / Re: FEW DAYS OR THE WHOLE MONTH IN RAMADAN
« on: October 16, 2013, 01:34:49 AM »
Salaam.

The hu - pronoun, third person masculine singular refers to its noun Ashshahr - the month (of Ramadan), according to the context.

In 2:183 we are just being introduced to the commandment regarding fasting.

God who knows the workings of our mind, and our timid nature, introduces us to his grand injunction of fasting as though saying: Do not be shocked! the fasting days are not numerous; they are numbered!

Then in the next verse (2:184) the actual number is specified as one whole month.

This type of narration by none other than the Almighty will be taken by the believers, only to mean that the month will actually pass as easily as a very few days!

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

198
Islamic Duties / Re: SALAT AND TASBIH
« on: October 15, 2013, 11:43:23 PM »
Salaam.

THASBEEH is the act or state of glorifying Allah. This is evident in every thing (17:44).

That is why we are filled with awe and admiration when we see or think about Creation.

The real scientists (not the commercial variety, who are dime a dozen in this world) who do genuine research, experience this awe and admiration to a greater degree!

In the above verse there is particular mention of living beings performing THASBEEH.

That means that we humans too are one with them in this aspect.

Additionally for us THASBEEH includes all our divinely ordained earnest actions amounting to glorifying the Almighty:

Desisting from everything evil, and doing good as much as possible: Doing, as the saying goes:

OUR UTMOST FOR THE HIGHEST!

Now let us take up SALAT:

It is the great, singularly edifying, preferably Qur’an-centric (3:13, 7:170, 17:78, 29:45, 73:4, 73:20) ritual which feeds and nourishes our THASBEEH (20:14, 29:45.).

It is time bound when it is congregational SALAT.

Otherwise the minimum of it is period bound, as it can be done anytime – within the daily – arguably – three periods (2:238, 24:58).

As far as Al Qur’an is concerned, the overwhelming stress is on the spirit of SALAT.

After all, heartfelt, earnest approach to Providence is what really helps.

Wallahu A’lam.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

199
Islamic Duties / Re: women and hajj
« on: October 15, 2013, 02:55:34 AM »
Salaam.

We cannot blame any government or organization for formulating statutes in order to curb obscenity.

Shirking all kinds of obscenities is one of the core values and on no account can core values be compromised. This is a common thread that runs through all Scriptures.

Guarding against obscenities is everyone's fundamental duty. Governments that host congregations like Hajj are also no less responsible in preventing obscenities.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

200
Salaam.

You said:

"I am sure you would like your views to be 'tested' in light of the Quran as I would like mine. This is how we grow in learning as I am sure you will agree."

Great! I agree.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

201
Sfalaam.

The lexical meaning of the word in question is, without dispute, to err.

The degree of the error in question, its graveness or grievousness, is determined by the context.

That is all.

Now for your genuine apprehensions:

Sayed Ahmed Bareily's contention that the Prophet is omnipresent, is openly discussed and convincingly refuted by Maudoodi in his thafseer.

By the grace of Allah, I do not belong to any extremist ideology - not even to any organization in the name of Maudoodi or any other scholar.

I took interest in this website merely in the hope, that it will help me in my endeavors towards understanding the Qur'an.

Your refusal to accept any other source other than the Book itself for its final, authentic and authoritative elucidation, is what keeps me here.

May the Almighty bless our cooperation.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait. 

202
Salaam.

(I)  In 93:7 the word relevent to our discussion is a noun, infinitive, and singular.

In 68:26, it's plural is used.

In 1:7 again, its plural is used.

In the above two places where the plural is used, as for 1: 7, there is absolute consensus that its meaning carries the gravest sense.

And, as for 68:26, there is again absolute consensus that it carries the softest sense.

The dispute is as regards 93:7

Regarding it I have already made my position clear.

(II)  As for 42:52, my stress is on ma kuntha thadree.

Here the root is DRY, and not 'ALM. Yet translators generally take it to mean: "you were not knowing". I said that it means you were not having the in depth knowledge that comes from patient persevering application of the mind.

That is why I said the verse doesn't say that he was totally ignorant of Al Eeman or Al Kithab.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

 

203
Salaam, brother Joseph Islam,and all members.

(I)   Since Al Qur’an is basically meant to guide mankind away from the torments of Hell, and towards everlasting bliss in Heaven, the error that drives man to a life of inequity and depravity leading him to the everlasting torments of Hell is called Dalaal. This word and other derivatives of its root: daud – laam – laam (DLL) are used in Al Qur’an overwhelmingly with respect to such an error. (example: 1:7 – the last word in the first Chapter.)

But in Arabic the same root is made use of to indicate any kind of error. Al Quran is witness to this:

For example, in 2:282, the root is used for an (unintentional?) error by a female witness.

In 20:52, it is used to deny any error on the part of God in the matter of knowledge of history.

In 68:26, it is used regarding a group of brothers, who, finding their garden unrecognizable (due to providential overnight devastation), exclaim that perhaps somehow they might have strayed from the right way to their own garden!

Going astray, away from the straight path (al sirath al musthaqeem) is one thing. Losing yourself in the search for Truth is altogether a different thing. We can very well understand the intense desire and eagerness to arrive at the Truth. At such a juncture, the Merciful God leads him to the Truth. (93:7). 

(II)   Being ignorant of Al Kithaab and Al Eemaan as in 42:52, does not mean ordinary ignorance. It means lack of in depth knowledge acquired through the ingenious application of the mind. After all, the Jews and Christians were conspicuous along with all their attributes, in the then Arab society. As such everyone would know something or the other regarding the Book, and also regarding Faith. The root word translated usually as knowledge here is not ‘ain – lam – meem. Instead, it is daal – ra – ya. It indicates in depth knowledge acquired through the ingenious application of the mind.

Therefore the enormous gravity of 5:5 is not present in 42:52. (Read on.)

To elaborate:

In 5:5, it is about rejecting Faith. That those who reject faith – their works will become null and void.

Rejecting Faith is quite different from not yet being thoroughly acquainted with the real truth regarding Faith, while still seeking the Truth with the utmost earnestness!

The words ma kuntha thadree ma al kithabu wa la al eemanu in 42:52 only means:  You had not yet arrived at in depth knowledge of either the Book or the Faith, - your heroic efforts notwithstanding.

(III)   a. 
The root gain – fa – laam (GFL) is not always about criminal negligence or senseless or foolish heedlessness.

After narrating the Ten Commandments, and after talking about the Torah, Allah draws our attention to the need for a new revelation in the form of Al Qur’an:

‘Lest ye should say: “The Book was sent down to peoples before us, and for our part, we remained unacquainted with all that they learned by assiduous study;”…’ (6:156)

 (At least because the diligent studies of the earlier People of the Book were in languages foreign to Arabs.) 

Arabic “Gaafiloon” is here translated as “unacquainted”, by Abdullah Yusuf Ali.

b.

Therefore, 12:3 must be read with the above background in mind. Prophet Muhammed was one among the Arabs, unread, and unfamiliar with previous Scriptures.

c.

In 24:23, Allah respectfully mentions innocent, chaste, believing women who are blissfully oblivious to, or unaware of in what way scandal mongers may speak about them.

For their being blissfully unconscious of such scandalizing Al Quran uses the same root gfl, and describes them as …gafilaath…

Therefore, criminal negligence, or senseless and foolish heedlessness are not the only senses or shades of meaning that accrue from the root GFL, according to Al Qur’an.


(IV)    As for the Prophet forbidding upon himself what Allah had made lawful for him, seeking to please his wives (66:1), this forbidding cannot be construed as a religious prohibition.

Because, religious prohibition amounts to telling lies regarding God, that He has prohibited such and such a thing while He never did so. And there cannot be a sin beyond this.

It is not at all reasonable to attribute such a sin to any of the Blessed Messengers of God.

What the Blessed Prophet did cannot be anything more than to keep in limbo a lawful thing – not specified in the Quran – until his wives would relent.

Allah forbids his Messenger not to take such extreme, unwarranted steps in order to please his wives, and also assures him of his mercy and forgiveness for what had already transpired.

(V)   As for 5:17, let us ask whether the Blessed Prophet Yusuf was ignominiously destroyed or merely caused to die, as every soul is destined, unambiguously, to taste death.

For, in 40:34, the Blessed Prophet Yusuf (Joseph) is mentioned, and for his death, the word halaka is used!

After all, even according to Lane’s Lexicon, ignominious destruction is not the only sense in which halaka is used in Arabic.

In 5:17, the root word halaka is used only with respect to the Blessed Jesus and the Blessed Mother Mary, and all other living beings on the earth, and this is clear by the use of the pronoun man in the verse. So that is about their death.

But, the phenomenon of death of a righteous person (16:32) is diametrically opposite to that of a sinner (16:28).

Let us speak respectfully of those regarding whom God has spoken with respect in 16:32, and several other places in al Quran.

May Almighty Allah count us all among His righteous men and women. Amen.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

204
Discussions / Re: farewell sermon
« on: October 08, 2013, 01:48:19 AM »
Salaam.

Q:  What would be his words that they were asked to pass on?

Ans:  Dear all, when (according to Wakas) there are several versions of the so called last sermon, is there any point in straining ourselves with the hadees? It is a blind street that will take us nowhere.

Wallahu A'lam.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.





205
Salaam.

Good reply, Shahmatt.

Moreover, there is no compulsion in religion because true guidance has been made clearly evident, and quite manifest, and distinguished from error. (see 2:256)

In order to make someone accept something unreasonable, compulsion may be necessary.

For a novice, first, it is the stunning universal appeal of the Majestic Opening Chapter.

Then the three verses 6:151, 6:152, 6:153, containing the The Ten Commandments - the Universal Core Values - may help in order to introduce people to Islam. At the end of each of these three verses, God appeals to reason.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

206
Discussions / Re: JOB
« on: October 03, 2013, 11:54:57 PM »
Salaam.

Job has been mentioned in the following places in Al Qur’an:

(1)    “… We sent inspiration to Abraham … Job …” (4:163)

(2)    “… We guided Noah, and among his progeny … Job …” (6:84)

(3)    “And (remember) Job, when he cried to his Lord: ‘Truly, distress has seized me, but You are the Most Merciful of those that are merciful’
“So We listened to him: We removed the distress that was on him, and We restored his people to him, and doubled their number, as grace from Ourselves, and a thing for commemoration, for all who serve Us.” (21:83-84)

(4)    “Commemorate Our servant Job, behold he cried to his Lord: ‘Satan has afflicted me with distress and suffering!’
“Strike with your foot: Here is (water) wherein to wash, cool and refreshing, and (water) to drink.
“And We gave him (back) his people, and doubled their numbers, - as grace from Us, and a thing for commemoration, for all who have understanding.
“’And take in your hand a little grass, and strike therewith’: Truly We found him full of patience and constancy. How excellent is the servant! Ever did he turn (to Us)!” (38:41:44)

Particulars regarding Job relevant to Al Qur’an are dealt with. No more. No less.

Regards,
A, Ismail Sait.

207
Discussions / Re: A sobering slap on the face of terror by Ghamdi
« on: October 02, 2013, 04:09:40 PM »
Salaam.

Other than videos, are scripts of Ghamdi's speeches available online?
Please reply.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

208
Discussions / Re: through the rain
« on: October 02, 2013, 02:35:44 AM »

Salaam.

Dear Hope,

“Say: O Allah! Lord of Power (and Rule) … In Your hand is all Good. Verily, over all things You have power.” (3:26)

Your post was quite awakening, and reassuring.

As I was reading it, it was as though I was transported to the sublime world of angels, the unswerving servants of God.

There is no doubt at all that God will get us through any difficulty.

If a heavy rain is a hindrance, the belief that He will get us through that hindrance is quite in order.

Letting us through (meaning, out of) any and every kind of predicament is of course God’s prerogative.

We have the example of Moses who said to his people who were under persecution, and, in dire straits:

“For help, seek God, and (wait) in patience and constancy.” (For the full verse, see 7:128.)

There is no doubt that patient perseverance takes time, and is a veritable, divine test for us.

God’s prescription, especially for illnesses is also the same: See 2:177.

Through the utter fury and astounding ferociousness of natural disasters, God saves whom He will. That has been demonstrated time and again at the end of the divinely mandated periods of the Blessed Prophets of God.

We witness it even today at the end of so called natural disasters.

So also every day throughout the world in what we call accidents.

How, or in what way, God alone knows.

“And your Lord said: Call on Me. I will answer your prayers. Verily, those who arrogantly refuse to adore Me, they will soon enter Hell, abased.” (40:60)

The mother and child dialogue shows that the child is progressing in the right direction. It also reveals the anxiety of the mother to guide her child aright.

Verily,

MORE THINGS ARE WROUGHT BY PRAYER THAN THIS WORLD DREAMS OF.

“So glory to Him in Whose Hands is the dominion of all things: And to Him will ye be all brought back.”
(36:83)

Regards,
A.Ismail Sait.

209
Discussions / Re: tadabbur
« on: October 02, 2013, 02:21:53 AM »
Salaam.

"...Therefore, you should first try to take few important verses of the Quran (the ones dealing with human relationships and character building) and try to integrate them in your life and studies..."

towards this end, the following release may be helpful:

                                                            THE TEN COMMANDMENTS
                                                  (Al Quran, Chapter 6, Verses 151, 152,
153)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Values evident in man’s pristine, pure nature.   Spiritual  Legacy of All Mankind.    Values that define all other values.                                                                                                       

“Say, (O Messenger,): ‘Attention! (O Mankind,) I recite The Inviolable Commandments of your Providence. They are, precisely, that ye

 join not anything with Him,
and be eminently kind and considerate to your parents;
and kill not your children because of poverty – We provide for you and them;
and approach not the obscenities – be they explicit, or implicit;
and kill not the being that God has made inviolable – except with absolute justification.
                       Thereby He entrusts you – for you to reason’.  (6: 151)   

‘And approach not the orphan’s wealth, but for the best, until they become capable;
and fulfill weights and measures equitably; We don’t burden anyone beyond their scope;
and be impartial when you speak, even if it’s about a near relative;
and The Covenant of God! – that fulfill!
Thereby He entrusts you – for you to realize’. (6: 152)

‘And that this is my path – it is the path of steadfast righteousness. Therefore follow it.
And, follow not The Ways. For, they will separate you from, and scatter you off His Way.
Thereby He entrusts you – for you to remain alert.’ ” (6: 153)
 
‘join not…’: “And fear a Day when no soul will suffice for another soul, nor will intercession be accepted from it, nor will compensation be taken from it, nor will they be aided.”(2: 48).    ‘…parents’: “…Be grateful to Me and to your parents…”(31:14).    ‘…reason’: “He allows filth to form upon those who do not endeavor to reason.”(10: 100).    Commandments 2, 3 & 4 teach priorities, responsible behavior, and dignity.   Commandment 5 proclaims unequivocally the inviolability of every human being, in every respect. Evident in the language of the Arabic original in 6:151, is the fact that it is ghastly even to think of killing a being that, being inviolable, should not be harmed or forsaken even in the ordinary sense. “And worship God, and associate not aught with Him; and be kind to parents, and also to relatives and orphans and the needy and the nearby neighbor and the distant neighbor and the companion by your side and the stranded traveler and your subordinates. Verily, God loves not the proud and the boastful.”(4:36).   ‘Thereby…’: These commandments He commits us to, in order that we  adhere to them with the most passionate diligence.  Commandments 6, 7, & 8 are sterling examples of fortitude, equity, and unfettered commitment.   Comms 9 & 10 safeguard Comm 1.    ‘that fulfill!’: The Covenant of God – “You alone we worship and serve, and You alone we resort to for help.”(1:4) – is what we are ultimately required to fulfill, following the aforementioned examples, in all the multifarious situations and contexts of whatever we do in life.   ‘realize’: intellectually as well as practically. ‘…scatter…’: “Dedicate yourself exclusively to His Commandments (Al Deen) – God’s pattern – upon which He fashioned Man. There is no altering (the pattern of) God’s creation. That is the Precise Religion. But most people know not. Repairing to Him, and be cautious of your duty to Him, and be earnest in prayers, and be not of the Imputers – the ones who rent their religion and became splinter groups – each sect exulting in its own tenets!”(30: 30, 31, 33)
 

For a tour of the different, yet homogeneous versions of the Ten Commandments, look up: Al Quran, 2: 83-84,  2: 177,  4: 36,  6: 151, to 153,  13: 20 to 22,  17: 22 to 39,  23: 1 to 11, plus 57 to 61,   25: 63 to 84,  31: 13 to 19,  33: 35,  42: 36 to 40,  70: 22 to 35. Revised, 8th edition, November 29, 2012. Compiled by: A. Ismail Sait, Punganur. Dial: 9502986955
                                                                                              READ ATTENTIVELY TIME AND AGAIN. REFLECT, COMPREHEND, REALIZE.

Since the release was copied and pasted, the original elegant format was lost. But the matter remains intact.

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.

210
General Discussions / Re: How best to respond to this objection?
« on: September 28, 2013, 05:26:45 PM »
Salaam.

Explicit statements like Jesus was born to a virgin are not in the Qur'an. The final authoritative statement regarding the birth of Prophet Jesus is: 3:59, 3:60:

The similitude of Jesus before Allah is as that of Adam. He created him of dust, then said to him: "Be": And he was.

The Truth (comes) from thy Lord Alone; so be not of those who doubt

Commenting of this, Abdulla Yusuf Ali writes:

"The truth does not necessarily come from priests, or from the superstition of whole peoplesl It comes from Allah, and where there is a direc13223t revelation, there is no room for doubt."

That  Moses split  the ocean and  turned a stick into a snake is the antithesis of Quran.

Moses had no hand in such things. They were the handiwork of God Almighty as and when He willed.

Yet, some exegetes have given what they call rational explanations to such narratives.

Conversations with animals are not that strange. Even ordinary people do it to a reasonable degree.

If a great and wise man like King Solomon could understand the gestures or whatever of a bird called hudhud, it is not at all surprising.

I, a lay man, can give you some feeble examples from my ownlife, regarding certain encounters with pet animals.

Yet, certain exegetes have interpreted the whole encounter of Prophet Sulaiman with Hudhud as being a dialogue between the king and a member of his intelligence department, codenamed Hudhud. Exegetes have proved this pointing to the language of the Qur'an.

See, for example: Thafseer Bayanullinnas of Kwaja Ahmeduddeen Amritsery. (for all the three above examples.)

Regards,
A. Ismail Sait.








Pages: 1 ... 12 13 [14] 15 16