Qurbani During Eid ul-Adha

[Reader Questions]

Salam Br. Joseph:

In Quran, God asked for qurbani during Hajj time.  But we muslims treat this as obligatory instruction that has to be followed during Idul-Azha when someone is in his hometown. Millions of animals are slaughtered all over muslims countries and lots of meat are wasted.  Even there is show of wealth with high bidding price of animals. What is your comment?

[Joseph Islam]

Salamun Alaikum,

With regards the need to sacrifice, I humbly find from the Quran it compulsory only for those who complete Hajj. Outside that (Those who celebrate Eid ul-Adha etc) it would be charity. However, I personally would strongly recommend charity as it has numerous benefits as well as atoning for one's sins. However, charity does not always mean that one needs to slaughter animals. Charity can be done in many different ways.

I hope that helps, God willing,
Joseph.